
From Sylvia Rivera to RuPaul: The Faces of Pride 1978-1996
Story by Jael Goldfine / Photography by Henny Garfunkel
Jun 19, 2019
Fifty years have passed since police broke into New York City's Stonewall Inn and began arresting and brutalizing its queer guests. As has become legend, the patrons of Stonewall fought back — shoving, punching and throwing stones — launching historic riots that would last six days. Within a year, the first Pride March, then known as the Christopher Street Liberation Parade, and the foundations of the contemporary LGBTQ movement were born.
Nine years later, photographer and longtime friend of PAPER, Henny Garfunkel (who captured Brooke Shields as a drag king for us in 1990) shot her first Pride march. A mainstay in the downtown gay scene of the '80s and '90s, headquartered at Club 57, Henny started going to Pride simply to support her friends like Tom Rubnitz, Keith Haring, Rollerina and Lady Bunny.
"As the years went by, the powers that be started to notice what a major community we were."
The colors, costumes and combustive emotions of Pride are any street photographer's dream, but for Henny, the event became a muse. She captured nearly every NYC Pride March between 1978 and 1996, a period of both radical vibrance and terrible pain for queer Americans.
"In the late '70s a bunch of people would just plan to go, you know? We would all march together. It was very joyful." she recalls. "Then the AIDS crisis came later in the '80s and it became a lot more serious and political. It became a protest. I mean, it's always been political. But as the years went by, the powers that be started to notice what a major community we were.
Henny's archive shows Pride as the shape-shifting phenomenon it is: a day that has become whatever the queer community needs. She shows Pride as a party, a protest, a funeral, and a battleground.
Lovingly lighting naked embraces and proud poses, her photos archive the euphoria of people living in a country that hated them, on a day that was a snaphsot of an alternative future. They celebrate the shrewd creativity of queer political speech and fashion, in the glorious shots of home-spun drag and kitsch protest art. They record the origins of icons, like RuPaul and Sylvia Rivera. They honor the rage and sadness, plucking out glares and silent screams, amid smiles and kisses.
"Pride had this conviviality: a little bit of Mardi Gras, mixed with Halloween. Just let your freak flag fly, that's the best way to put it," Henny describes.
Her images don't neglect the hatred lurking just on the other side of the barricades, exposing the counter-protestors who used to gather along the parade route and at St. Patrick's Cathedral. Among the attendants, they also trace the trajectory over time, of queer culture's precarious relationship with the mainstream, as increasing numbers of "Grandma for Gays," and "I Love My Lesbian Daughter" apparel and and politicians like Rudy Giuliani join the ranks in her photos, while "allyship" and the "gay vote" became household terms.
The fact that Pride looks different now — like Coachella, stripped of radicalism, compliant with police, bloated with rainbow capitalist cash from investors who don't question how their day-to-day business hurts queer people — is something of a broken-record conversation. "Now Apple or Chase Bank has a float. There was very little advertising back then," Henny remembers. "It's slick, but back then it was rough, homegrown. It was more which tribe you were associated with, the Pyramid Club or whichever."
"Remember that you're standing on the shoulders of the people that brought this, like Marsha P. Johnson and Sylvia Rivera and all the people who fought the fight. Celebrate that.
Queer culture's reckoning with its rising appeal to the mainstream seems to become more existentially complex each June. "Everything changes. The world is caught up to gay culture, in some ways. RuPaul's queens are on the cover of New York Magazine," Henny says. "We live in a really strange time, a horrific time. Trans people are still getting murdered. AIDS isn't a crisis, but healthcare is. It's not a good time for gays right now, even if they get the cover of magazines and some communities celebrate them. I think the larger culture doesn't want to see this."
However, as someone who witnessed the much-glorified "then," Henny isn't necessarily nostalgic. "Am I nostalgic? I was lucky to live through it, to see it. But I'm not nostalgic for losing people. It was like a war, a war was going on. So I'm not nostalgic for that time. I'm nostalgic for a certain wildness I suppose. But it's just a different time, you know? It's just a different time totally. It can't be that way now."
An indisputable beauty of Pride is opportunity for reflection and remembrance. Half a century after Stonewall, and as World Pride converges on NYC, it's more crucial than ever to remember how we got here, however we conceive of this place. So this June, PAPER asked Henny to pick 100+ photos from her archive to help us remember.
"Have the greatest day possible, just remember that all this came before you," Henny says, asked what she hopes her photos will mean to young people. "Remember that you're standing on the shoulders of the people that brought this, like Marsha P. Johnson and Sylvia Rivera and all the people who fought the fight. Celebrate that. Celebrate the history. Celebrate who you are. I think that's still hard for lots of people."
Photography: Henny Garfunkel
From Your Site Articles
- Google Arts & Culture Launches "Art Transfer" - PAPER ›
- How You Can Help Save the Stonewall Inn COVID-19 Closure - PAPER ›
- Stonewall Inn Has Been Saved, Reopens July 6 - PAPER ›
- 35+ Photos From NYC's Queer Liberation March - PAPER ›
- NYC Pride Bans Police From Parade Through 2025 - PAPER ›
- Chicago House Pioneer Paul Johnson Dies at Age 50 ›
- NikkieTutorials Honors Marsha P. Johnson at the Met Gala ›
- Lena Dunham Criticized For Wanting Her Casket in Pride Parade ›
- NYC Pride Is Canceled ›
- A Nearly Complete Oral History of NYC's Pyramid Club - PAPER Magazine ›
MORE ON PAPER
Music
PinkPantheress Locks In
Story by Erica Campbell / Photography by Reto Schmid / Styling by Max Weinstein / Makeup by Julian Stoller / Hair by Anoushka / Nails by Juan Alvear / Set design by Milena Gorum
Story by Erica Campbell / Photography by Reto Schmid / Styling by Max Weinstein / Makeup by Julian Stoller / Hair by Anoushka / Nails by Juan Alvear / Set design by Milena Gorum
12 May
Music
Alesso Surrenders to the Sound
Story by Felicity Martin / Photography by Tre Crews / Styling by Joe Van O / Grooming by Jenny Sauce / Set design by Liz Mydlowski
Story by Felicity Martin / Photography by Tre Crews / Styling by Joe Van O / Grooming by Jenny Sauce / Set design by Liz Mydlowski
24 April
Film/TV
Coolest Person in the Room: Hannah Einbinder
Story by Joan Summers / Photography by Diego Villagra Motta / Styling by Angelina Cantú / Hair by Jerrod Roberts / Makeup by Mia Jones Siegel
Story by Joan Summers / Photography by Diego Villagra Motta / Styling by Angelina Cantú / Hair by Jerrod Roberts / Makeup by Mia Jones Siegel
15 April
Music
Kesha, the Barefoot Baddie From Tennessee
Story by Hilton Dresden / Interview by Bob The Drag Queen / Photography by Brett Loudermilk / Art direction by Zain Curtis / Styling by Marta Del Rio / Makeup by Leo Chaparro / Hair by Eduardo Ponce / Nails by Britney Tokyo / Production design by Krystall Schott & Michael Avina
Story by Hilton Dresden / Interview by Bob The Drag Queen / Photography by Brett Loudermilk / Art direction by Zain Curtis / Styling by Marta Del Rio / Makeup by Leo Chaparro / Hair by Eduardo Ponce / Nails by Britney Tokyo / Production design by Krystall Schott & Michael Avina
03 April
Entertainment
Dylan Mulvaney Finds Her Light
Story by Harron Walker / Interview by Lily Drew / Photography by Davis Bates / Styling by Erik Ziemba / Makeup by Laurel Charleston / Hair by Angelina Panelli
Story by Harron Walker / Interview by Lily Drew / Photography by Davis Bates / Styling by Erik Ziemba / Makeup by Laurel Charleston / Hair by Angelina Panelli
07 April