A Butthole Surfers show is big news these days. Head Butthole Gibby Haynes has been living in New York City, but the band hasn't played with the original members in quite some time. The last stop of their tour -- organized by Paul Green of School of Rock -- landed at Webster Hall last night. The house was packed and all went well until... PAPER's senior editor Carlo McCormick gave the following report: "The show almost turned into a riot. Finally fed up with the lousy sound, Gibby got into a heated argument with the sound man, that escalated to a level that made security escort him off stage and out of the club -- in the middle of the show. This did not exactly sit well with the capacity audience, who stayed in the club for more than an hour later screaming and throwing things. It was all so punk rock it was almost hip hop."

TONY and Billboard have complete reviews of the show. And check out the YouTube video above of Haynes performing with School of Rock band.